Ad
  • Custom User Avatar

    I was using Python. I passed it already. Thanks for your help though.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I'm so satisfied with this kata! I was up all night trying to figure it out. I learned a lot from this and I appreciate the creator and contributors for this kata.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I cannot reproduce this problem with your current Python solution either.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Yes, it seems to me that negative numbers are tested.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Python, but I've gotten it to work already. I'm having trouble with passing the last attempted test because of timeouts. It also shows at the top Passed: 30 and Failed: ?

  • Custom User Avatar

    In what language? Negative numbers should be tested, but without knowing the language, I do not know where to check.

  • Custom User Avatar

    Your solution passes some thests and then either crashes, or times out. It is difficult to tell without knowiing your code, or the language you are attempting. I cannot reproduce this problem with your current C# solution.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I don't know if it's my CPU or something but everytime it hits the last one it shows execution error and says Passed: 30 Failed: ?. Does anyone know what this means?

  • Custom User Avatar

    Are negative numbers actually being passed to the fib function? When testing for negative (if n < 0) the condition is never met.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I appreciate your explanation and I'll do my part in making sure that I fully understand any kata as much as possible. I truly understand the concerns stated above and I honestly should have asked the question rather than raising an issue. I have done some research on this topic to fully understand it and I'm practicing as we speak. It is a challenging kata and appriciate you and the contributors for providing it.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I did not claim that understanding the task was common sense, everyone can make mistakes. I misunderstand or miss things in descriptions often, too, and only realize it when I submit my code and see that it does not pass the tests.

    What I meant by common sense, as I wrote, and as explainedhere, was that when you think you have found a really big mistake, especially in a kata with so many completions (and 38,500 completions is massive), you should stop and think:
    Did I understand the task correctly ? Am I solving the right problem ? Did I miss something in the description ?

    Only after double checking everything, scrolling down the discourse page to see if there have been similar remarks / reports in the past, you should open an issue. Issues should not be opened lightly, as:

    • they create more work for the volunteers who curate Codewars content, who will check the issue report, try to reproduce / analyze it, and possibly submit a patch
    • accumulating bogus issues discourage people from trying a kata, and encourage newbies to blame the tests for their own mistakes, thereby opening yet more bogus issues.

    I did try to explain the mistake in your logic, too, but you kept focused on your own interpretation of the task instead of on what the description explains.

  • Custom User Avatar

    @trashy_incel bro watch how you talk to people. There are plenty of ways to express yourself particularly when it comes to someone trying to figure things out. If you knew I didn't understand something, rather than telling me about common sense, then you should have at minimun replied with a link to some help. It obviously wasn't "common" to me. Sometimes it's how you express things and not about the assumptions you're making about the programmer. Yes, I raised an issue because I thought there was one but you could have replied with:

    "you must be unfamiliar with this kind of problem here's a link to something that'll help you understand it more".

  • Custom User Avatar

    I'm actually doing my due diligence and learning more about this and practicing a whole lot more. I thought I knew what was going on but I completely misunderstood the entirety of the kata (conceptually). I was so focused on the procedural aspect rather than trying to truly understand it.

  • Custom User Avatar

    I'm actually doing my due diligence and learning more about this and practicing a whole lot more. I thought I knew what was going on but I completely misunderstood the entirety of the kata (conceptually). I was so focused on the procedural aspect rather than trying to truly understand it.

  • Custom User Avatar

    and stop raising issues when you do not understand something in a kata; it is rude. an issue implies there is a serious problem with a kata, that other regular users (volunteers) will have to analyze, debug and fix. when you are confused, ask a question.

  • Loading more items...