What is the logic to be adopted when you have to rotate after G. Example. If you start in F# and need to rotate 7, in which letter/note do you need to stop?

And related to zero specifically, zero is positive

My friend, in my first attempt I was wrong, but I came here and saw the Chrono79 comment, paid attention to the description and the examples, tried to solve in my mind and conclude that the description and the example test cases, at least in Ruby (as Thiago Pelizoni always says, Ruby "what you take from life", just kidding), are good. In the first round, from nothing to a positive or a negative number, you do not have a change. I think this is the "trick" of this Kata.

如果PHP的内置函数都不够好，那凭什么要求我做得更好XD。

Very poor description, but the Kata is not bad

Rejected:

• No random tests

• Outdated version

• assertSame should be used

Rejected:

• No random tests

• All tests always pass because the actual function is not tested against

• Actual and expected are swapped

• Outdated PHP version

• Missing <?php and <?php use PHPUnit\Framework\TestCase;

Rejected:

• No random tests

• Should've used assertEquals for better error output

• No need to throw Exception in solution

• missing static declaration for initial solution setup

Adjusted, thanks!

Look at the argument order in the random tests.

The fixed tests are fine, it's the random tests that still do it wrong.

Same of the previous comment:

User answered with 2000

Right answer: 1

System says: "2000 should equal 1"

If I invert the order result in a wrong answer:

1 should equal 2000. No, should equal 1.

I think I did not understand the problem.

You have 90K (kyu). I think you have the privilege to edit the kata. If you do this, please explain your change.

Or please help me to understand better.

Thanks

No, not OK.

Argument order is still wrong in random tests.

It's in the Example tests as well, but to see that you may have to refresh if you opened the trainer earlier.

Adjusted. Seems ok in the tests, but I did the same changes in the example tests and the changes was not exhibited in the example tests :(

About the order, please see the message returned:

"20000 should equal 1"

I forced the function in my solution testing the kata (I am changing the user solution, not the kata) to return 2000. In this case the message returned looks like ok, right?

Message returned: "20000 should equal 1"

2000 -> what user returned
should equal 1 (1 is the right answer).

Ok, right?